496 Cary St, City of Orange, NJ Every day, 7:00 am to 7:00 pm Free written estimates
RJ ConstructionRoofing · Siding · Since 1990 Call (973) 625-7663
RJ Construction crew on the roof of a two-story house during a roof replacement
Blog

Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingles for Your Next Tear-Off

Your old shingles are coming off. Here is how to choose between standing seam metal and new shingles, and what to make every contractor put in the quote.

For metal roofing vs asphalt shingles, our rule of thumb is this: if you plan to stay in the house a long time and the roof is fairly simple, standing seam metal earns its higher upfront cost. If you might sell within a decade, or the roof is cut up with dormers, valleys and walls, architectural shingles are usually the smarter money. The exception is the cut-up roof itself. People assume metal always wins on longevity, but on a complicated roof the flashing details and the labor to fold them decide both the cost and how well the roof performs, not the panels.

Most of the roofs we look at in Essex and Passaic counties are aging shingle roofs where the old layers have to come off anyway. That tear-off is the moment to make this choice, because the deck is exposed and every option is on the table. Below is how we think it through on site.

What is the difference between metal roofing and asphalt shingles?

Asphalt shingles are overlapping tabs of fiberglass mat coated in asphalt and granules, nailed through the face into the roof deck. Architectural shingles, the thicker laminated kind on most North Jersey houses now, are the standard replacement. Standing seam metal is long steel or aluminum panels that run from the ridge to the eave, joined by raised seams, with the fasteners hidden under the seam so nothing punches through the weather surface.

There is also exposed-fastener metal (screwed-down panels, common on barns) and stone-coated steel, which is stamped to look like shingles or tile. Both are different animals from standing seam. Exposed fasteners mean rubber washers that age and need checking. Stone-coated steel has its own trade-offs, covered in the FAQ below.

How the two compare on a full tear-off in North Jersey
FactorArchitectural asphalt shinglesStanding seam metal
Typical service lifeRoughly 20–30 years40 years or more with a good finish
Upfront costLowerHigher, often by a wide margin
Install timeUsually fast on a typical houseSlower: measuring, panel forming, detailed flashing
Snow and iceHolds snow; relies on ice barrier at the eavesSheds snow; needs snow guards over doors, decks and walkways
RepairsEasy to patch a few shinglesDamaged panels are harder to swap
Complex rooflinesHandles dormers and valleys wellEvery valley and wall adds labor and risk
Low slopesPoor below a modest pitchHandles lower slopes well

When asphalt shingles are the right call

  • You may move within the next several years and want the roof done right without paying for decades you won’t use.
  • The roof has several dormers, valleys, skylights or a chimney tied into a sidewall. Shingles adapt to that shape cheaply and reliably.
  • You want the house to look like the rest of the street. In many older neighborhoods, Montclair included, shingles match the architecture.
  • Your budget needs room for other work the tear-off reveals, like rotted decking, new gutters or better attic ventilation.

A properly installed shingle roof with ice barrier at the eaves, new flashing and real ventilation is a very good roof. Most of the failures we tear off are not bad shingles. They are worn-out shingles on an attic that never breathed, or flashing that was reused from the roof before. You can read more about how a full shingle tear-off goes from start to finish.

When a standing seam metal roof beats shingles

  • You plan to stay put and would rather not do this again.
  • The roof is a simple shape: a gable, a straightforward hip, a ranch.
  • Part of the roof is low-slope, like a porch or a rear addition where shingles keep leaking.
  • You have had ice dam trouble at the eaves and want a surface that sheds snow and ice.

Metal’s real strength in our climate is shedding. Heavy wet snow slides off instead of sitting for weeks, and that cuts down the meltwater that refreezes at the gutter line. The flip side is that the snow has to land somewhere. Over a front door, a deck or the driveway, plan snow guards, and expect gutters under a long metal run to take a beating unless the guards are placed right.

Metal roofing vs asphalt shingles in Northeast weather

North Jersey roofs deal with freeze-thaw cycles, nor’easter winds and the occasional oak branch. Here is how each material handles them in practice.

  • Ice dams: shingles depend on ice-and-water membrane at the eaves and in valleys. Metal sheds ice, but still needs a good underlayment beneath it.
  • Wind: standing seam panels with concealed clips hold well. Shingles hold well when nailed correctly; most wind blow-offs we see trace back to high nailing on the old roof.
  • Falling limbs: shingles bruise and get patched. Metal dents, and a badly dented panel is a bigger repair.
  • Noise: over a solid deck with underlayment and an insulated attic, rain on metal is quieter than most people expect. The loud metal roofs people remember are panels over open framing.

Lifespan and warranty: what actually lasts

Lifespan only pays you back if you are there to collect it. A metal roof that outlasts your time in the house still adds some appeal to buyers, but don’t count on getting the full difference back at sale.

Warranties are where comparisons get muddy, because separate kinds of coverage get lumped together. The manufacturer’s material warranty covers the shingle or panel itself. A metal roof’s paint finish warranty covers fading and chalking, which is a separate document worth reading. Workmanship coverage is the installer’s promise about leaks caused by the installation. Ask for each of these in writing and compare them side by side, or see how roof warranties work in plain terms.

How long does each take to install?

A shingle replacement on a typical house moves quickly. Customers often tell us the complete removal and replacement on their house was done in a single day, with the yard cleaned up and the dumpster gone soon after. That depends on the roof, the weather and what the deck looks like once the old shingles are off.

Metal takes longer. Panels are measured and formed to length, colors sometimes have a lead time, and every trim piece around chimneys, walls and valleys is bent and fitted by hand. Expect a few days on site, not a single day, and a wait before work starts.

What drives the price difference, and what to ask each contractor to quote

We don’t publish price ranges here because a figure off the internet is wrong for most houses. Metal costs more upfront mainly because the material costs more and the labor is slower and more skilled. The gap widens on roofs with lots of valleys, dormers and penetrations, and narrows on simple shapes. For more on this, read about the factors that drive a roof’s cost.

The bigger problem is that quotes rarely cover the same scope. Ask every contractor to spell out these items so you are comparing like with like:

  1. Tear-off of every existing layer down to the deck, and disposal.
  2. How damaged decking is handled: priced per sheet, and how many sheets are included, if any.
  3. Underlayment type, and where ice-and-water membrane goes (eaves, valleys, around chimneys and walls).
  4. New flashing at chimneys, walls and vents, not reused metal.
  5. Ventilation: ridge vent, intake at the soffits, and whether the attic actually needs changes.
  6. Drip edge, and what happens to the gutters during the job.
  7. For metal: panel material and thickness, seam type, finish warranty, and snow guard placement.
  8. For shingles: the exact shingle line and whether matching manufacturer components are used.
  9. Workmanship coverage, in writing, with how long it lasts.

If two quotes don’t list the same scope, you are not comparing roofs, you are comparing guesses.

How we decide on site

Standing in the yard, we look at four things: the roof’s shape, its pitch, where snow will land if it slides, and how long the owner expects to stay. A simple roof, an owner staying put and a clear landing zone for snow point to metal. A busy roofline, a possible move or a tight budget point to shingles. On many houses, from North Haledon to the Oranges, the honest answer is a good shingle roof now, with metal on the low-slope porch or addition that keeps giving trouble. If your current roof might have more life in it, start with whether to repair or replace.

Common questions

What is the typical cost difference between a metal roof and shingles?

Standing seam metal costs noticeably more upfront than architectural shingles, and the gap depends mostly on how complex the roof is. Simple gable roofs narrow the difference; roofs with many valleys, dormers and chimneys widen it because metal trim is slow, skilled labor. The only reliable way to know is to get both options quoted on the same scope for your house.

What type of roof adds the most value to a home?

A roof that is new, leak-free and suits the house usually matters more to buyers than the material itself. Metal can appeal to buyers who want a long-lasting roof, but you rarely recover the full extra cost at sale. If you plan to sell soon, a well-installed shingle roof is usually the practical choice.

How much does a metal roof cost on an average-size house?

Square footage alone won’t give you a fair number. Pitch, the number of valleys and penetrations, decking condition, panel material and snow guard needs all move the price. Ask for an itemized quote after someone has actually been on the roof.

What are the downsides of stone-coated metal roofing?

Stone-coated steel can shed granules over time, can be dented or scuffed when walked on, and costs more than shingles. Its seams and fasteners differ from standing seam, so it doesn’t shed snow the same way. Ask how it handles your roof’s valleys and walls before choosing it for the look.

This week, ask every contractor you’re considering for the same written scope, using the list above, and ask them to quote both materials. Then decide based on how long you’ll stay and how simple your roof is. If metal is still in the running, see what a standing seam metal roof involves on a North Jersey house.

Keep reading

Free estimate

Not sure if yours is a repair or a replacement?

Call (973) 625-7663 for a free estimate anywhere in North Jersey.

(973) 625-7663